Friday, October 27, 2006

Subliminal Chauvanistic Messages



Check this website out:
http://www.snopes.com/language/document/goodwife.asp

Now I know where the messages came from: The website above is an actual article that was printed from the 1955 Goodhousekeeping Magazine. When you're done falling on the floor from laughter, forward this to some other women friends of yours!


(From and Editorial I wrote for the Concordia Newspaper back in 2004)

Whatever happened to “all men and women are created equal?”

You may be thinking, “Here we go again; another complaint from a woman who feels she has not been treated as an equal.” However, there are messages I hear embedded in everyday comments communicating subliminal messages that women are not equal intellectually or in status, whether in the home, church or workplace. Though these comments made by men may not be intentional, they need to be addressed.
Case in point: I was at a Christian concert a couple of months ago when the male recording artist talked about how excited he was that his wife was pregnant with their first child. He blurted out that he hoped that their first child was a boy and proceeded to act out his fantasy of playing ball with his son. But then, jokingly with a little tongue and cheek sarcasm, he added, “Well, I’ll be glad whatever sex the baby is, even if it’s a girl, because a healthy baby is what is really important!” What if his first baby is a girl and she wants to play baseball? Will he be disappointed?
My sister was more interested in sports than I was and really liked to play softball. My dad worked with her for hours and she became an excellent pitcher! What if the recording artist had the boy he wanted, but his boy wanted to be an artist or ballet dancer? What then?
I probably wouldn’t have been as bothered by his comments, if the singer hadn’t already made fun of his own voice because he was a tenor. He kept apologizing for sounding “like a girl.” I thought, “What’s wrong with sounding like a girl?”
Another male tenor at the same concert had previously mentioned, somewhat uncomfortably that he sounded like a girl, too. I began to wonder if there was a conspiracy against male tenors who might “sound like women.”
After I purchased a new car, another interesting experience occurred. Yep, that’s right. I, a woman, went out without my husband and purchased a new car. I wanted a safe car that was going to be dependable, got good gas mileage and had 4-wheel-drive. I didn’t really care about the color of the vehicle because it was more important that the car would be equipped with all the things I needed. At one point, the salesperson asked what color I would prefer and seemed a little surprised that I didn’t really have a preference. After my car purchase, my husband began talking about what is most important to women when purchasing a vehicle. He said, “When women are looking at cars, the first thing they do is find one in the color they like!” I said, “Whoa…wait a minute, you mean ALL women think the color of a car is most important?” He said, “Yes.” I asked him where he got his information. Much to his chagrin, he answered, “I read about that in my advertising class back in college!” I quickly asked him, “What year did you take that class?” He replied, “1983.” Twenty years ago? I don’t believe that color is the most important priority to all women when purchasing a vehicle.
These stereotypes imply that women don’t really put much thought into buying a car. In reality, most women and men put much thought in major purchases such as cars. Every day, I researched information, visited several car dealerships, and spent a lot of time reading and comparing information between before making my purchase.
Pointing out these negative messages can make a person unpopular. However, there are subliminal messages that minimize women that we become conditioned to hearing and accepting. Women need to recognize these messages and speak up when sweeping generalizations or preferences are made. To women and men who think that women are being treated as equals when very subtly we are being “slammed” by chauvinistic comments, I want to say, “Wake up! And listen to what is really being said!”
There are men who recognize positive gender differences and appreciate contributions and see the importance of female voices in shaping future generational thinking. This mutual respect is critical by men towards women.
If women just sit back and let words go by without questioning the thinking behind the comments, then maybe we are foolishly perpetuating the stereotype that women are less intelligent!

2 Comments:

At 10/29/2006 9:04 AM, Blogger Cheryl said...

I had a similar experience when I bought my first car as a single female. I had taken my boyfriend at that time with me and the salesmen kept trying to draw him into the process. I was amazed that even though I was the one with the checkbook, they thought somehow he was more intellectually able to make a decision regarding a car. They most noticeably became agitated with me when I haggled with them regarding the price of the car. Clearly I was overstepping some invisible line.

Even though, we've "come a long way baby" (I just dated myself) I too see there are still some chauvenistic phrases tossed about from time to time. However, I would have to say that now, 20 years post buying-my-first-car experience, I don't think that the majority of chauvenistic comments or situations arise out of cognitive desire on the part of the male to inflict ill will on females, or even that the male really believes what he is saying, rather I think it reflects on the man's own security and comfort level with the opposite sex.

In my opinion the proven theory that 'to every action there is an equal and opposite reaction' is true in society as well. A side effect of women becoming "equals" in society (which isn't "wrong")is that the movement has created a generation of men who are uncertain as to what it means to be a man. While we laugh at the article you posted (which was very funny and amazing!) roles were clearly defined and at least both sexes knew what the expectations were! Men are bombarded these days with mixed messages of expectations and what it means to be a "real man", creating confusion, uncertainty and self-doubt. Not condoning chauvenistic remarks, but out of understanding, I can see where it would be easy to flip into "default mode" and let seemingly socially-acceptable remarks flow off ones tongue regarding the opposite sex. (I've seen it go both ways.)

As a woman, I agree that we need to take note of these phrases or remarks and challenge the ones saying them not just out of defense for women, but for the man's sake as well, to help them in their growth process as they wrestle with their identity as a man and how they relate to women. Mutual understanding, respect and appreciation of one another is the goal, isn't it?

As the mother of two girls and two boys, I feel it is my obligation to educate both gender sets regarding the opposite gender and the importance of abstaining from stereotyping, but rather appreciating one another as individuals, gifted with different strengths and abilities.

Just as a side note, I find it interesting that in our "progressive" American society where women do have rights and tauted equality with men (most noticeable when compared to some other cultures and societies that I have witnessed) the pornographic industry is bursting at the seams and pocketing fistfuls of money from objectifying women. What's wrong with this picture??

Just makes you wonder how far we've come!

 
At 10/30/2006 6:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Paula, Subtle is a kind word. Blatant is my main experience. Especially within church structures. Women are openly and consistently degraded, dehumanized, and "kept in their place" in church settings. Anything the rest of the world dishes out in our culture becomes subtle compared to such atmosphere.

My biggest complaint regarding the world outside of the church is that women's worth is in sex appeal. But inside the church, the degradation is in just about every form imaginable.

But it is through those experiences that we learn what chauvanism is and is not. It's a disease. The "subtlty" is merely rotten fruit off the diseased tree.

Anonymous

 

Post a Comment

<< Home